San Miguel Vs Fernandez 381971

c a

c

c

c



c

c



a a a

a

! " #$ aa a ! aa %#" "aa # #$ &" ' aa ! # a (# a # a # aa ( a ) %#" "aa #

a * '' % # aa ( +! , - ( .aa # aa ! - aa +,+,#" # / !)) ! a ! 0 a ! # a aa 1 # 2 a ) + 3 4, " a 5a % 6 # a #! 7 8 # aa # # 3 / '5'4'5'44 ! 1 #*0 9 #$ ! ! ! ! # * +3 a ,#. 5' / a! 5"aa % )aa i.e a 6 aa 2 a 5"aa " : ! # 0 aa 2 a "aa " #$ aa # 5"aa % )a 3 / '5'4'5'44 a #certiorari!

0

aa # a - (a (a ! # 2 a ) * a ; +, (a (< +, a # a # = # a a = +, a# = +, # a # a a ! # #=

+, # aa aa # aa ! ! # = + , a #! a a 7 ! = +#, 7# a 6 a != +', # < +, - aa 0 a # = +, # a ! # # 5a a = +, ( #( " a a )%"" = +, a #a # 5 # # aa < +, ! a # a = +, a aa a # aa



a a ! # " ! - a a aa ( a ( a aa a #! < ! icipality of Cotabato v. Satos (105 Phil. 963)! ) 0 a ! # aa a # # a ' Bislig Bay L ber Co. v. Provicial Goveret of S rigao (100 Phil. 303) ! )a a#! < # a a ! a# ! aa # a a a# ! a a ! ! aa a# # a # aa a # a # # aa ! # ## a ! # a # ! # ! a a 1 ! 6 a ! aa a # # - # ! #1 '#) " / >

"aa ! a ! a# a Xerick v. Twi Lakes Reservoir Co. (144 Pacific 884)" ! ! ! ! # a# ! (! a ! ! a ! ( Otario Silver !iig Co. v. Hixo (164 Pacific 498) # ? 1 a##! a a !! #!#! ! < 8 ! # a# # @ #! #! ! ! ! & 1A a # a## ! # a # a a! ! # a a - a aa ! <

6a aa ! ) + ! - ,! # a # #! ! ! ## a a ! # " B! 2 a ) +) C D )%"" 1)2"'4, 8 ! ! 0 a # !0 ! #a a # 6 # *E2"B)&# a +*E ) )%"" 1)2"'>, aa 6 ! a #! aa ! ! ! # aa +*E2"B)&1 )a )%""1)2"'4, a ! aa a## a +.58 ) )#B4/ E >', 0 ! ! a a # # # ! aa a a +1&) #/ !@ ") "' '>, 2 a ) ##( aa ( a a ( aa a ## aa ( # #! aa" # )) a a #! < " #! aa +,B #0 =

+,E # ! a #! 0 # - 1 '#) " / > ! 0! " B!a ( aa a ( a # a 1 # " # ! # a # # # a aa a F1 +0,# 2 a ) # a #! < +0,a ; aa a a #! a a# !# aa a (# # a # reasoably peraet i character ( ) & a## a ! # ! ! a # a # a E ! a a a## ! ! # ! # #! # a 0 a# # # # a !a ! ! a # # ! " a #a # a ! a ## 0 & " )%"" G 0 aa ! ### aa # ## % 6 excl sively # ## a ) a ! a - # a ! # a a # . # !aa ! a a0 # # ! a a # peraece itee i its costr ctio a se a (a ( aa a a a a a aa ! aa a ## a ! # aa ) - # ! ##(a ( a #a * # # aa " # )) 0 1 # 2 a ) )! - aa a 6 " # ( #( 2 a " a # ( #( #! <

" H aa a ! ! # 0 ! 0 # # 0 # H # 7 # )%"" #!- #< 8 # aa # # 3 / '5'4'5'44 ! 1 #*0 9 #1* $ ! ##+ ,a a 6 # + 1/a >@ ,1 #*0 9 #$ ! ! ! ! # * +3 a ,#. 5' / a! 5"aa % )aa i.e a 6 aa 2 a 5"aa " : ! # 0 aa 2 a 5"aa " # $ aa # 5"aa % )a 3 / '5'4'5'44 5 a# ) a #6 5- 0 )%""! # # # # 6 # a a # a a ! ! # # # ) # !a! # ! ! 8 ! ! # a )%"" 0 7 # # aa # a a a! ! a # # aa )%"" ( ! a 0 a! " +, - # a # B% ! sagg ia # B% sagg ia+, %#aaa ( # 5! a ) a # # 0 8 # # # a # 6 # aa # a # 6 : ! a - a # 5 # # aa 8:E2E.&2E a 31*11E3## ! 6 # a ) %#" "aa ! # a a #a a a ! 1E "13E ) a

c a c !"!# $#%&'%# c$ c('% c'( #

)*c'(

& & a )) / 45% (!argarita D. Va. e Iperio, et al. vs. ! icipal Goveret of Sa !ig el, B laca, et al ( )#. #%"a'> -

a a a a #! <

8:E2E.&2Ea - ## a## # *aA #1* % a *** A " *a < a # 3 #3 ) a # # *a#1* % & '>> # B / ' %0#1 5' ! #44 6 ! ) / 5# 2 #3 #% # *aA #1* % ' # a3 #2 # # ## a## aa# 5 #+I, # a## *3 9 a "2#)E "# ) @ @ a 5 #+I, ##a## * E B= # aa a## aa a aa #4 a # a # a# a #>a> a #@>#a= #! aa # 6 ## a## aa# =

# a a## # # # #

=a

# # #0# a 1&&23E2E3 +aa 5'2, # - #! a aa ! # # aa ! ## )#"aa )"5A 2 / 15' )A 2 / # a a # #!# # ## - 2 a - @'>' !< ) #- =

@ 'A 2 / B5

) # aa a## # @'= B !# a # # +a 2, @'# *J !# a aa # a# a# 6 ! ! a - " '' !# ## ## &1 a ' a - ! a < # # # # - *a * )2#1* % #%" & # a! - @ " ) % a 0 a #1

* % 0 ! #a## a # aa a## # !# . # a # +, # a#a# &## # . #%! ! ! a +a '2, 8 +aa,# a! #1 a ' a - # ! aa # : a a ! # # *a#1* % # aa #%1* a a # ! a# # ## - )) / 45 % 8 a# - # ! a #*a#Paoay vs. !aaois4 4'( # a a # a # aa #! aa - aa a# ! a # aa ("Tatoco vs. ! icipal Co cil of Iloilo '! ( # ! aaa a # a ) 7 ! @ # a # - ### # ! - ( # #a a a # *a #1 * ! a # #% a# a# % 3 a <

/ >>0! ( 3

B. " (1 '+,

1E) ' F aetal Priciples ;B ### a # aa # < +,/ a# aa #!#aaa a # & ! aaaa ## a 1% # # a a ! 1% a ## . 1 2 # / !2 #) a # # # - < +,% aa # ! a ! a# a# aa ## # - #

## aa # aa = +,% aa a= +,%a - 5 # a =

! # -

+,% - 5 # ! - # #

#!

"))&23/ABK a # a - @'>' #!# = !# @'>'= # a - 1 a ' #% *a #1* %a! - 1E "13E= a - #a !# a

c $#%&'%# )'$! )*$!!#)*+( % c$,, a aa # # a @ B2 ) / /5 >B2)2 / /5 (2 <"aa#2 # *E )aaa( *' # a *E )a# aa# # a # * *3 > &" >>4aa 6 aa # a #2/+E E,! 6 # # A / 3 #&" 1 3 '>+E E, "aa a 55 a aa a#! # aa ! # aa # aa+E , a+E @@5, &*' a @ # aa # a a 3 #B a a #! aaa# # "# ! # a ) a a 3 # B 6 ! ! + 3 #B "aa )" !L9 ) / B5>'+3 '4,41)2" 3 #B : % 73 )a / +@'>,D ## ## ! „ce )a a a a # a# a a ! #! a a # 6 a ipso j re! #- a a aa " ) < / # a #a ! # a 6 # a # 1 # # a + ,(

a

a # A # #

(/a# a a#a ! # ! a # 6 # = !# a 7 a !origially # aa # ## + ,# 6 a #a a

) # ! private * #/ a >) a # a a +>) " M91 , aa ! a aa### 1 #)! "/ B" " „ce # #a ! a a (a # # a ! ## # #! a # a () a / # # !! a a aa ! ! 6 8:E2E.&2E a 3E/E3 6 # a @ "..2*E3 1&&23E2E3

a## 5aa # 5aa



& #* / B@ 9 E 2 7. * E 9 % B9 : 7) # !# %a # # ! a :* ! a # a 0! * % 0 )= # ! ## 5a a# - 0 2 aa = # 6 # ! # ## # # a## a #!#! ! a## - ! a )B0 #! aa2 . ! # ! # a # a # a # ! a aa2 6 # a## # ! a = a! #! ! # #!# ! ! a a - a # a## # 0 - # # - a #!#! # aa # a## ! a - #a - # a a # ! # # # # #= a- - # # a a## # a = # 6 aa ! # a !# a a## ! # # ' #" # ! # # a ## aa ! #! # a ! ! #% #! ! ! # "a B = 1 a a #%# a= # a## a a

?a a #* > - a## ! # # a # a # aa2 aa #% ! # a # ! a#= # # # # ! a# 6 # a ! ! # a - # 0 # !! ! a aaa# # a 6 ! /! # ! aa a ! a## # ! -0 ) a ! # a# # ! aa2 = ! ! # # a## ! #! ! ) B0 # aa2 !#< ! ) # # aa #a ! # aa2

## )a ! #=! # ! # ! - # a ! # # # 5 # # # a a # ! # # # ) # !a " # )) a a # # # ## ! ##! ! # ! - # a ! a # 0 #)= ! ! a = # ! a # a !# ## # % "

'# ) a < B! ! ! ! # # ! ! ! / ! # ! !0 a # !0

" 4# < # # #! ! # a ! a # a ! B!#8 #" 44 #! # ! a < B ! - ! #!! !0## ! ! !

: ! # ! !0 !a a a !a # ## ## ! = " a #! # # * !0 ! 0 a aa2 # ! ! # # a## = # !! a a # ! # # ) # 7 ! #! # a a # * !0 0 # a ! ! ! ! a #! a aa a # ! #!# # a## 0 #) aa2 : !#- ! # aa2 # ! # aa a## a a # a## ! # ) 0 ! 0 # a ! # #- # aa #a ! # aa2 # !

#) 0 a## a # #a ## ! = # a #!# ! aa2 ! ) 0 a # a # ! # . a # # ! - aa # # ! # ! # :* ! # a ! #!# ! # )B0 # # a## # aa2 = # a # ! ! # ! ## aa2 = # #a #!# ! # - aa # ## # ! a ! # aa 1