Aarushi-postmortemsept09.pdf 5u4e6g

RC 1(Sy0B/SC-llllDLl

D rlo Pmt : 8-136 Further Statement of Dr. Sunil Dohare S/o Shri Ramdaval ryal Dohare Sector - 19, Noida. 30. a4.1 968 DOB: 1gg4 -AllMS. MBBS: (DPH) (Sponsofed Candidate) : 2O05 KGIllU, Lucknow PG: !

ir!

ii

I had been examined on 18.07.200g a;:t;3.10.2008 when my statement was recorded. I have seen mjr statements and I confirih that the content of lhese statements are corect to thelbest of my knowledge. 'i;

"t,

My professional experiencs._ is as follows

:

1

Nathp".rhakri, Jhakri

18 months till February, 1998.

2.

UP Health Service

Since 1.5.1998

/:\

Ai Danapur, Dibai, PHC,

1

\r,

lz months

Bullandshahar (ii)

At Jonchana, Jevar Block, G.B, Nagar.

(iii)

At T.B. Clinic, D. H. Sector-3O, NOIDA.

(iv)

At UP Bhawan dispensary

Carnpus

Tall

20a3

'!

Till 20A4 For 1%Years.

-3:

il

Iitt

l'

(v)

At PHC Sector

Ji tt

- 22, NOIDA 'r-'t

I: Ti

Continuouslysince 2006. .

J!

ti

:..

Today, you have furthtir'bxamined md'on various aspects relating to the injuries

by me during the postmortem examination pf deceased Aarushi.

tr

observed

ti li

to my postmortem report no. 356/08 dated 16.05.2008 which has been signed by me.

This refers

::!_

t$ J!

E H t: t$

E

F

I state that on 16.05.2008, I was in a meeting (Pulse Polio) at PHC Sector 22, Fp41A, Noida. The meeting was chaired by SMO, Noida. lt was around 11:30 am when

Il

I

received a

cdl on my cell

pHqitr1e

from District HospitraEEmergency stating that there is a

to reach the PM House: lt WaS about 11:45 am by - t;: gate of PM House bed sheet was placed near the fsa

thit

I maroon inared a time. A body in

a

gdte of PM Hciuse. Oi. Oinesh Tatwar approached me and introduced himself. HddS-ked me about the Mediddl College I have graduated fromI told him that I have edMBBs from AllMS. HeitolO me that he was a faculty in I was standing near

i

I i'

l,

i.

I, ft :

i,. #n ;

i

i[..e-

Opthalmology Department, OJ AllMS. He ast<6d-.rhid':ff I.was'competent enough to conduct PM. There was another Doctor by the Sumdqe of Verma. He also introduced himself and told that he was.also a graduate of AIIMS; Both of them gave their visiting cards and also told me that they were presently working in Apollo Hospital, New Delhi. the meanwhile Mr. Tyagi,'Pharmacist arrivedJtook brief history ot the circumstances

... teaOing to the death of the girt from Dr. Dinesh Tatwar.'ind a policeman. I was told that

the seryant has killed the girl 'dnd has run

away.

1-r'

Mr. Tyagi and I were. sitting in the room nerd*b the room where actual PM is done. I looked at the police pppers. Body of the girl wps being shifted to PM room wilh 'a the help of relatives- t took rough paper and'wai abodt to enter the PM room. Dr.

I

t

it t

l3

t

['

-t. a

r. tr t I

[: l 3

I E

II g

tt:-

t \I

me to speak saying that Dr. Dogra Dinesh Tatwar 94ve me his g.9ll phone an{ ":l"d was on the other end. The person on the other end asked me my name etc and told me I I to t"t

"

the blood sample of th'6 body. I told him not to Worry as all needfulwill be done.

:ii

The seal of the coveripg bed sheet was being ppened as I proceeded towards the pM room. I entered the $lvl,,room. Mg.. Dfne?! gnp;Mr; Aiay were in the room. The clothes of the body were removed in my presen@.,{rere were three clothes on the

body - (1) Top .Q) Pajama*(3) Panty. I did the e5ternal

I

t It I

I

examination of the body.

Checked for rigor mortis. Rig.-of Mortis was present in lhe upper limbs there by meaning that time of death was about q-12 hours earlier. I noted./own the number of ear tops on the ears. They were 5 in nur4ber. I looked for any defgnce wound. There were none.

I

looked for any bite marks or gqratches on the face, breast, back, etc. There were none. l..,[

.

.,,

;i

.'*

iij

-'*

it I

i':+

.

.'?

semidigested food in the stoiBach implying that the degth of the girl has occurred within

2-3 hours'of the last rneal. Flrtigt were normat. Bottf:chambers of heart were ernpty. ii. .. ! Cervix and part of vaginal ca$tV and uterus were takgi out of the body. Linear incision was made and found whitish"frrid in / around cervix.

tJLf out the fluid and made a slide

of the fluld also. Preserved if.lb uirc"r" of the body

t,n"r" r"s no oefence wound. I

wanted to rule out any poi"o'iing. .POpened the skull of.the body.l found fracture of skull on both left and right sides. T.f.rere was hematoma present corresponding to the fracture

showing that this was first iniury. The fracture originqied on left side and traversed to

right-siffikull.

I came out of the PM room with rny rctes and started making the j.1(

report.

'l'':;

.

?.

Ravinder Tyagi was making the entry in the . Mr. Dinesh brought the Jars, -vl'

Slides and Clothes in to the,room and sealed the following things :-

Viscera

(1)

.

(2) Slideg* (3) Report

r: ..

- 2 Copiep. F:

(4) Clothes.

Lr

Handed over the repo'it alongwith above itemd;to the police, left the PM House

and went home.-'.Before I bffi.ttle policeman.asked tn€,if there was any penetration or sexual assault on the girl? I iSfO f,ir that I have made*the slide. There was a lady also who asked me the same

queslion. "

.;i Question

.

Answer: :

Answer:

/

,yestion:

-.i

'-r.

What according{o you was the time of de3th? Time of death --'2-3 hours following last riiaat. ,,:i!.

Question

:.-

'j.

rt

ln yggr PM Repgrt, y9u have written thq-lhe of death as 1 to 1 Tz days. How do you explain it? I have taken one'day equal to 12 hours. -i* -' t .:ii r-j :r! During your exainination you have foun{ certain pgg{@1Jaqts about the private parts of the body but the same hdve not been mentiondd in the PM Report. Why? r". .t.i

Question: Answer:

in entire

RC &AC.

w

Before ffie,

(A.G.L. KAUL) DSP/CBI/SCUlXDelhi Camp Ghaziabad.

(D

ti::